Unceasing Prayer

Before Abba Isaac began his second conference on prayer St. John inserted a historical account of a disagreement among the Egyptian brethren, which provided the background for this conference's topic. This theological disagreement dealt with how man was made in the image of God. One party's failure to properly understand how man was made in God's image caused detrimental blasphemy to the Orthodox faith at the time (10.1). St. John related how Bishop Theophilus of Alexandria sent a letter (A.D. 399) to the monasteries in Egypt arguing against the Anthropomorphites who were a group that assigned physical, human characteristics to God. This letter sparked a controversy, because a large number of the monks thought that man was literally created in God's image. Among those caught in this error was Serapion who was an aged, pious monk (10.2.2).  Abba Paphnutius received a learned deacon at the monastery in hopes that he would settle this dispute amongst the brethren. The deacon pointed out to Serapion and the brethren that man is the image of God in a spiritual sense rather than in a physical sense (10.3.3). After realizing his error Serapion was greatly distressed, because he had to give up his anthropomorphic image of the Godhead, which he had always mentally envisioned during prayer (10.3.4). In tears he cried out, "Woe is me, wretch that I am! They have taken my God from me, and I have no one to lay hold of, nor do I know whom I should adore or address" (10.3.5). How many of us ignorantly fall into such errors? This error is why the Church forbids mental images during prayer--because we could end up praying to our image of the Trinity instead of the Holy Trinity. By such an error we could even run "the risk of everlasting death" (10.4.1). We could ignorantly undo all spiritual progress, as Serapion bitterly experienced. How can we expect to properly unite with God when we do not rightly understand Him from the beginning? Nevertheless, God's grace is sufficient, and he that seeks God finds Him.

St. Gregory Palamas and Hesychasm

"Today we will be speaking about St. Gregory Palamas and the essence of hesychasm. The Council of Constantinople in 1351, which took place 650 years ago, clearly and definitively affirmed the experience and theology of hesychasm. The first such council had met ten years earlier, in 1341, at which Palamas and his Athonite monks presented the Hagioritic Tome, in which they set forth the essence of their experience and of their theological confession against Barlaam. Later, in 1347, another Council met, this time against Akindynos; by then Barlaam had already left and become a cardinal, a bishop of the Pope, after which he took up the fight against hesychast theology.

So, concerning the theological experience and justification of hesychasm:

Hesychasm, of course, is not a new phenomenon. You will find it in the book of Archbishop Basil (Krivoshein) as well as in that of the Russian Byzantologist, George Ostrogorsky, who lived with us [in Serbia] and had a brilliant career, giving significant weight to Serbian Byzantology. He himself was Russian, but had many students, including Greeks. He wrote about this in roughly 1936, at roughly the same time as Hieromonk Basil (Krivoshein), even a bit earlier.

Hesychasm is a prayerful life, a life with love; at the same time, it is a mystagogical and liturgical life in which, following one’s purification from the passions, one attains a profound experience and taste: the vision of the glory and grace of God. It is not simply a means of preparation for prayer, as Barlaam had initially thought and even certain ignorant monks had explained, in which one must press one’s head to the chest, follow one’s breathing, and gaze at one’s navel. That is nonsense, and St. Palamas criticized it. Of course, it is essentially to become focused, but this is not meditation. It is not meditation, but a deepening in prayer, so that the mind would descend into the heart, which is the depth of man’s being. As the Savior said: For out of the heart proceed evil thoughts (Matthew 15:19)."

Read the rest of Bishop Atanasije's talk here and here.

Prayer of the Heart

The original Conferences were numbered at ten. Only later were other conferences included in this work to satisfy the needs of the brethren. Part II, Conferences 11 - 17, was written for Saints Honoratus and Eucherius and covered topics not previously mentioned at length in Part I. The former saint desired to establish his cenobium after the traditions of the desert fathers, while the latter desired to travel to Egypt, as Saints John and Germanus had previously done. Part III, Conferences 18-24, was written for the monks Jovinianus, Minervus, Leonitus, and Theodore who had established several cenobium in the Gallic provinces in and around modern day France. St. John Cassian comments that the first ten conferences were "put together haphazardly at the command of the holy Bishops Helladius and Leontius" (Conferences, Part II Preface, 1.2). All this being said St. John intended Abba Isaac's two conferences (IX & X) on prayer to be the fulfillment of a promise given in the Institutes, as well as the culmination of the first eight conferences.

"The aim of every monk and the perfection of his heart direct him to constant and uninterrupted perseverance in prayer; and, as much as human frailty allows, it strives after an unchanging and continual tranquility of mind and perpetual purity" (9.2.1). Establishing the virtues simply and humbly on the Gospel Rock is necessary before pure, interior prayer can be achieved. The beginning of pure prayer is acquiring the virtues and casting off the vices. Thus, a virtuous life and ceaseless prayer in the heart are inseparable.

The Way of the Ascetics

"Chapter One: ON A RESOLUTE AND SUSTAINED PURPOSE

IF you wish to save your soul and win eternal life, arise from your lethargy, make the sign of the Cross and say:

In the name of the Father, and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost. Amen.

Faith comes not through pondering but through action. Not words and speculation but experience teaches us what God is. To let in fresh air we have to open a window; to get tanned we must go out into the sunshine. Achieving faith is no different; we never reach a goal by just sitting in comfort and waiting, say the holy Fathers. Let the Prodigal Son be our example. He arose and came (Luke 15:20).

However weighed down and entangled in earthly fetters you may be, it can never be too late. Not without reason is it written that Abraham was seventy-five when he set forth, and the labourer who comes in the eleventh hour gets the same wages as the one who comes in the first.

The Gulag of Pitesti

"Slavery to ideas is as serious a form of slavery as any other. Through His Church, Jesus offers you the deep mystery of His Divinity and His friendship. you are no longer called a slave but a friend if you discover the mystery of divine things." - Fr. George Calciu (Fourth Meditation, Sermons to Young People)

Watch the entire four part video here.

More can be read about Fr. George Calciu here and here.

Metropolitan Kallistos Ware on the Jesus Prayer

A Forerunner of the Jesus Prayer

Abba Isaac in his second conference on prayer sets forth a formula for ceaseless prayer:

"O God, incline unto my aid; O Lord, make haste to help me." - Psalm 69(70):1 

He goes on to teach that ceaseless and pure prayer is learned similarly to how a child learns to write by tracing letters daily over a long period of time (The Conferences: 10.10.1).  Therefore, a simple prayer, also called an arrow prayer by St. John Chrysostom, should be constantly repeated to control the distracted and wandering mind.  St. Chrysostom prescribes a different formula for ceaseless prayer in his hourly prayers for the twenty-four hours of the day, yet the end goal is the same--to obtain a pure heart that constantly abides in Christ.

Father Seraphim Rose on Orthodox Living

"Prayer, fasting, vigil and all other Christian practices, however good they may be in themselves, do not constitute the aim of our Christian life, although they serve as the indispensable means of reaching this end. The true aim of our Christian life consists in the [increasing] acquisition of the Holy Spirit of God. As for fasts, and vigils, and prayer, and almsgiving, and every good deed done for Christ's sake, they are only means of acquiring the Holy Spirit of God." - St. Seraphim of Sarov